Hi I have this problem (using 4.0 beta 2):
If I set Notify moderators ON (in Moderator group selected only SAdministrator) than e-mail notification about new comments to SAdmin e-mail works fine. The problem is, that registered users of the web, when they are logged on, if they send new comment and choose Not notify in the form, the comment is posted even with green envelope icon as Notify and the user is getting e-mail posting of all replies to his post - even he selected Not notify. When I go to Content setting and set Notify moderators OFF and keep Enable users notification ON, than there is of course no e-mail notification about new posts to SAdmin email, but yeah the comments of the registered and logged on users with Not notify selected are posted with orange envelope icon and the user is correctly not e-mailed with replies to his comment. So there is propably some connection between Notify moderators and Enable users notification. Could you correct it please? Thank you very much.