TOPIC: Notify moderators VS Enable users notification

Hi I have this problem (using 4.0 beta 2):
If I set Notify moderators ON (in Moderator group selected only SAdministrator) than e-mail notification about new comments to SAdmin e-mail works fine. The problem is, that registered users of the web, when they are logged on, if they send new comment and choose Not notify in the form, the comment is posted even with green envelope icon as Notify and the user is getting e-mail posting of all replies to his post - even he selected Not notify. When I go to Content setting and set Notify moderators OFF and keep Enable users notification ON, than there is of course no e-mail notification about new posts to SAdmin email, but yeah the comments of the registered and logged on users with Not notify selected are posted with orange envelope icon and the user is correctly not e-mailed with replies to his comment. So there is propably some connection between Notify moderators and Enable users notification. Could you correct it please? Thank you very much.

Hey phizzy,
I tried to repeat the steps to get the same bug, but it works fine for me.

I have Notify Moderators set to on and the groupd is SA. i'm notified of new comments. When a registered user posts a comment and he choose do not notify, then he is also notified about new comments.

Could it be a template problem? which joomlacomment template are you using?

Hello
Im using modern joomlacomment template. Ive disabled the user notification and keep just moderator notification for now. And now Ive spotted, that when I send a new post, it has good time stomp, but when I send a reply for some comment, it has +1 hour. The hosting server has good timezone set, the Joomla has good timezone set and both new comment and reply was sended by the same user (good timzeone in profile set). So Im quite confused. Ill try to set another joomlacomment template now.

Yee, when I change the joomlacomment template to default, than the timestomp is good in both new comment and reply.

Could you start a new tread about the timestamps. It doesn't make sense for me, but I'm going to check it. It doesn't matter if you reply or write a new comment - the same function to display the date is used every time. Is it possible that the user has a custom timezone in his profile?

Now I finaly know whats the situation (I hope . Ive badly understood what does Notify and Not Notify mean. I thought that Notify means the user will get e-mail notification about the reactions just for his concrete one post only (If another user reply to his post). But If I understand well this function means that the user will get e-mail notification about ALL comments to the selected article. So this is what I dont wanna use.

The user will be notified about future comments to this article. Yep, this is what the function does.