More info,
The comment was being attached to the correct article after matching it as stated. The problem is/was that the comments are not being published. The joomlacomment component lists them as published. If you unpublish each one and then republish them, everything works correctly.
Upon examining the database, jos_comment is listing a value of "2" for coments that should be approved (or were in WP). The value in my wordpress database is 1. After I go through the unpublish/republish the value of the joomacomment database is 1 and everything works.
Any idea why the values of 1 in my wordpress database are given a value of 2 upon inmport. Is there an easy way to fix this besides manually doing each one. I could batch them but then I would be approving a lot of spam comments and then I'd have to deal with them.