Hi Daniel,
I know I am being very literal in reading your suggestions ... sorry if I've misunderstood here. I can not "deselect" the admin user ... seems when one group is selected, no option to deselect all...
What if I turned off the toggle "Notify Moderators"? I was afraid that doing this might also turn off the notifications to the content creator also.
The site is in production now, so didn't want to do more testing to figure this one out.
If you think these settings are 'correct' (see attached) for having only the contact creator to get notifications, I will test this.