Joomla Components and Professional Joomla Templates

      
    | 

13th of March 2010

Joomla Backend Mastery - FREE webinar - find out more here.

Hidden links/advertisement

( 15 Votes )

This blog is intended to all of you using !joomlacomment 4.0 alpha3. I was really dissapointed to read the editor's comment on JED.

Here is a quote:

" Editor's Note

  • This extension by default includes hidden links/advertising. Hidden links/advertising can affect the Search Engine ranking."

I want to tell this to all of you out there! There are no hidden links or hidden advertisement in alpha3. Yes, it is true! In alpha3 there is an experimental advertisement feature. It was not very good implemented from my side. It is turned per default on, but you are able trough the backend to turn it off. I want to say that I stay behind my name! I will not implement something that will harm in any way your websites! My goal is to provide you with the best possible user experience when using joomlacomment or other software, that this site produces.

Something more: alpha3 is only for testing purposes! Your feedback is valueble to me and that is why in beta1 the advertisement feature will work in a different manner! It will be turned per default off and you will have to specify if you want to use it or not.

With all that said, I hope that we didn't loose your trust in !joomlacomment! Stay tuned for joomla comment 4.0 beta1 introducing akismet and gravatar support :)

Comments (21)
  • Anonymous
    avatar

    When?

  • Torgrim Sandvoll  - Feature requests
    avatar

    Hi,

    What I would really like to see is:

    Buttons on the comment heading for sorting by Date by userrs (newest/oldest) and Votes (most/least). The default sorting should also be an option for admin (eg. if I like my sites comments to be sorting by most votes by default).

    Replies collapsed by default only showing the main comment, and users can open the replies if they like. (less space and chaos).

    Good luck with version 4 and best wishes!

    Best regards,
    Torgrim Sandvoll, Norway

  • Daniel Dimitrov
    avatar

    About your first suggestion "sorting buttons" - nice feature, but it is not ready for 4.0. It will make it in a next release.

    About your second suggestion:
    you can make this already. Just use another template :)

  • Rganey  - Turning off adv
    avatar

    "Yes, it is true! In alpha3 there is an experimental advertisement feature. It was not very good implemented from my side. It is turned per default on, but you are able trough the backend to turn it off."

    what steps do i take to turn it off. I love the import feature and want to use your mod but my client will not accept this feature being turned on.

  • cassy
    avatar

    will the new version be set up so that integrating it into other components will be as easy as with Jcomments or Jomcomments?

  • cassy
    avatar

    aha! now looks to me like I first need to write a plugin for remository before I can integrate?

    hmm! just what I don't consider as attractive. the aforementioned JComments & Jomcomment only require adding a couple lines to remository or any other component for integration. this commenting component however appears to be requiring additional code to being added to the commenting component as well, i.e writing up a plugin

    JComment and JomComment are therefore much more attractive. sorry!

  • Daniel Dimitrov
    avatar

    We don't have any plugin for remository right now - nobody asked for it in the forum(so far I can remember). That is why there seems to be additional work, but if we have this plugin(as we have one for docman) then the only thing you had to do was - enable the plugin, add 2 lines to the repository template and ready to go.

  • cassy
    avatar

    right! any chance a plugin for remository can be added then? would I need to post something in the forum for that purpose?

  • Daniel Dimitrov
    avatar

    I've just added your wish to the wish list:
    http://dev.compojoom.com/issues/show/51

    I don't know when I can start to work on this. I'm currently working alone and there are a lot of things to do for the beta1 and other projects. This is definitely something that we will have :)

  • cassy
    avatar

    thank you! :)

  • Leonid
    avatar
    Code:
    <h4 style=”display:none;”>!joomlacomment 4.0 Copyright (C) 2009 Compojoom.com . All rights reserved.”</h4>
    wrote:
    We try not to index or not to rank high:
    ...
    Pages with poorly visible or invisible text or links,


    (yandex.ru)

    Maybe Editor's Note influenced by hidden H4 element?

  • Daniel Dimitrov
    avatar

    Well, the h4 element is per default not hidden, but visible!

    Read this:
    http://compojoom.com/faq/28-remove-qpowered-byq-.html

  • Leonid
    avatar
    wrote:
    Just add the following line in the css of the joomlacomment template (or joomla template).

    #poweredby { display:none; }

    Yes. This one is really visible and ok:

    Code:
    function insertPoweredby() { return '<div id="poweredby" align="center" class="small">Powered by <a target="_blank" href="http://compojoom.com">!JoomlaComment '."4.0alpha3".'</a></div>'; }

    but this one seems like hidden:

    Code:
    function insertHiddenCopyright() { return '<h4 style="display:none;">!joomlacomment 4.0 Copyright (C) 2009 Compojoom.com . All rights reserved."</h4>'; }


    Am i wrong? (!JoomlaComment4.0.0 alpha3; joscomment/comment.class.php; line 410)

  • Daniel Dimitrov
    avatar

    #poweredby { display:none; } after parsing invokes the insertHiddenCopyright() function.

    This function is never called if the user have not hidden the logo!

  • Leonid
    avatar

    ok then :-) But here and here and on your site both of them displayed, even if CSS rule #poweredby {display: none} does not exists:

    Code:
    <div id="poweredby" class="small" align="center">Powered by <a target="_blank" href="http://compojoom.com">!JoomlaComment 4.0alpha3</a></div>
    <h4 style="display: none;">!joomlacomment 4.0 Copyright (C) 2009 Compojoom.com . All rights reserved."</h4>


    Is it a bug?

  • Daniel Dimitrov
    avatar

    Yep, seems like bug to me. Will try to fix this for beta1.

    Added to redmine:
    http://dev.compojoom.com/issues/show/52

  • Leonid
    avatar

    By the way, hidden div#poweredby with hyperlink inside could be even worse for yandex.ru. I'm clueless.
    Is it acceptable to completely disable rendering of div#poweredby?

  • Daniel Dimitrov
    avatar

    Of course! If it is hurting your web site! I also think that with the next version I will remove the inserthidden version. Who cares? If you satisfied with the product, then you will show the link to our page :)

    Go to the comment.class.php - inserthiddenlink is invoked in one place, just remove it and it should not display anymore.

Write comment
Your Contact Details:
Gravatar enabled
Comment:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img]   
:angry::0:confused::cheer:B):evil::silly::dry::lol::kiss::D:pinch::(:shock:
:X:side::):P:unsure::woohoo::huh::whistle:;):S:!::?::idea::arrow:
Security
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

Our sponsors

Newsletter




Who's online

We have 1097 guests and 3 members online

Support us!

Our Blog

Joomla Backend Mastery - free Webinar! (23)
09.03.2010, 07:57:
I had a look over compojoom's forum last days. There are always some people that ask obvious questions in my eyes: "The comments are not showing" - we ...
Read more

Advertisement